Page 1 of 4

JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Tue Nov 05, 2013 8:36 pm
by pinksoir
I'm thinking about buying one of these two synths. If I were to buy a JX-3P I'd more than likely get the KIWI-3P mod done (and the PG-200). If I were to buy a Polysix I'd get the CHD midi kit for it.

To my ears, judging by the demos on youtube, both are great sounding synths but very different and covering totally different sounds.

The Polysix:

Is quite dark sounding but has a great filter and VCOs.
Only 1 EG
Ensemble/Phase/Chorus
Seperate LFO for PWM


The 3P:

Has a classic Roland tone and 2 DCOs per voice.
Has osc sync.
Only 1 EG
Chorus
No PWM so to speak.

I like them both a lot but could only afford one right now.

How do you rate them?

Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Tue Nov 05, 2013 8:59 pm
by commodorejohn
I'm of the opinion that you can't go wrong with the JXes, but I have to admit I've been hella impressed by the Polysix demos I've heard (damn you, whoever beat me to that free one in the Bay area!) Either would be a great choice.

Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Tue Nov 05, 2013 9:27 pm
by pinksoir
From the demos I've watched online I've heard more interesting sounds and possibilities from the 3P. Like, I'd have a video playing in the background while I do other stuff and every now and again some really cool patch will come up and I'll be really impressed. But the Polysix sounds really great, period. So the conclusion I've come to is that the 3P would be a very versatile and useful synth, but the Polysix would just sound great, no matter what it's doing!

Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Tue Nov 05, 2013 11:00 pm
by synthroom
I have a JX-3P, but not the Poly SIx, so I can't speak to the Korg.

The 3P has two oscillators, and the envelope generator can be inverted giving it a whole extra range of sounds that a lot of synths don't have. It can make some really interesting, grungy, and odd sounds.

Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Wed Nov 06, 2013 7:29 am
by moremagic
if its workin get the polysix
if it aint get em polyfixed

Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Wed Nov 06, 2013 11:30 am
by pflosi
Both very cool synths. What I really like about the JX3P is its nice poly sequencer. On the P6, love the chord memory.

Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Wed Nov 06, 2013 1:24 pm
by pinksoir
I bought a JX-3P. It excites me a bit more than the Polysix, though I still have a soft spot for that synth. But listening to demos, I'm already getting lots of ideas for sounds. I've been using the TAL UNO-LX vsti quite a lot in my stuff lately and find it to be a good workhorse for filling up certain areas sonically.

With that in mind I was considering a Juno 60 or 106, but doing a bit of research on the 3P piqued my interest a lot. The extra DCO is a huge benefit, and the X-mod sounds gorgeous to me. It sounds like it can cover the Juno type sounds pretty well, though it doesn't sound quite as nice as the 60. But unless I had them side by side I doubt I'd hear the difference. The bonus is that it can go places the Junos can't. Slight bummer is the lack of PWM, but it can do pseudo PWM with the cross mod, so all is not lost. Plus the PWM on my CS50 is just amazing, so I'm not too fussed.

I don't think I'd really use the poly sequencer much if at all, but with the KIWI upgrade it has a bunch of possibilities opened up. Chord memory, Unison, portamento, extra LFO, full MIDI implementation...

Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Wed Nov 06, 2013 3:20 pm
by pinksoir
This is a sweet little demo that shows off quite a lot of the variety of sound available from the 3P. That sync sound that comes in half way through (1.58) is one of the nicest I've ever heard. I was never much of a fan of sync until I heard that! Just gorgeous.


Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Thu Nov 07, 2013 12:18 am
by Pro5
>>

Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Thu Nov 07, 2013 7:50 am
by commodorejohn
pinksoir wrote:This is a sweet little demo that shows off quite a lot of the variety of sound available from the 3P. That sync sound that comes in half way through (1.58) is one of the nicest I've ever heard. I was never much of a fan of sync until I heard that! Just gorgeous.
Oh wow. That almost makes me wish I had a 3P instead of my JX-10...think you made the right choice, man.

Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Thu Nov 07, 2013 1:12 pm
by pinksoir
Yeah, I feel pretty confident about it! There is a JX-10 for sale locally actually, but no PG-800 and the dude is looking for €750 for it. They seem like very different machines though, despite being in the same 'series'. Each have their pros and cons. Some nice pad sounds from the 8P/10, but for me I reckon I'd get a lot more mileage out of the 3P.

Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Thu Nov 07, 2013 6:36 pm
by Dr. Phibes
I got both too and I think you made the right decision going with the JX-3p. The polysix is great but limited and I don't think it would add much to what you already have. The 3p isn't a Juno and it probably won't do what people love in Junos as well but I offer a much broader sound pallet.

I can vouch for the KIWI mod as well, pain in the arse to install (mostly because of the fiddly desoldering of the PSU) but it really expands your synthesis options.

Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Fri Nov 08, 2013 2:28 am
by Pro5
Some of the Juno vibe/filter but with Dual Oscs and unique sounds. 8P/10 are completely different. The tone around 50 seconds is really nice. And for a synth with software envs it doesn't do too badly.




Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Fri Nov 08, 2013 1:19 pm
by pinksoir
@Dr. Phibes

Good to know the KIWI mod is worth it. I bought the 3P from Modeless Factory and he said he'd install KIWI for no labour charge as he's overhauling the synth anyway. It is ~€200 extra though. I was considering waiting til I get the synth and seeing how it is without the KIWI mod first though. Which would you recommend?

@Pro5

Some very un-Juno like tones in there. It does sound (from videos I've watched) that it can get pretty close to bread and butter Juno sounds.



This dudes comparison is pretty good. It's cool because roughly half the sounds sound clearly better on the Juno and half on the 3P. That being said, the 3P can achieve stuff that the Juno never could, which I like a lot.

Re: JX-3P VS Polysix

Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2013 1:46 am
by ppg_wavecomputer
I used to have both. Sold the Polysix, bought a second JX3P.

It´s a lot more flexible, has a very nice little on-board sequencer, two oscillators per voice, and a lot more going for it in terms of scope.

The P6 always sounded like a deluxe string synth to me. As nice as the SSM filters are, I grew tired of it very quickly.

Stephen