Roland JX showdown: JX-3P vs JX-8P vs Super JX10

[vuuv]

haha, the TX was more "well the lately bass is cool, maybe I'll finally learn fm, and it's cheap!" but the jx+pg looks like a sure thing right now

[commodorejohn]

Man, the TX81Z is capable of so much more than "Lately Bass."

[nathanscribe]

Indeed. 4-op FM can sound really plasticky and rubbish if you program it sloppily, but with a bit of attention to detail you can get some surprisingly smooth sounds out of it. The only thing to watch for on the TX-81Z is the aliasing that taints some high-frequency elements in some kinds of patch. But there are plenty of good sounds in that unit besides the one or two famous ones.

[commodorejohn]

Personally I kinda like Yamaha FM's high-frequency aliasing, it never sounds junky and can add kind of a spacey edge to certain sounds. But yeah, there is that.

[vuuv]

I probably will still grab a TX at some point... I might wanna play with some fm soft synth first, though, since it's so foreign to me. A rackmount fm synth might not be the best intro for me!

[commodorejohn]

Most soft synths don't quite capture the real sound of Yamaha FM (what I've heard from FM8 is pretty close, but a lot of others are more "almost but not quite,") to be honest. And I don't know of any that offer multiple operator waveforms like the TX81Z does, which is key to its wide range of sound for a 4-op FM synth...

[ninja6485]

FM8?

[commodorejohn]

Oh, can you? Looks like. I stand corrected, then.

[Dr. Phibes]

X10 and 8P sure don't deserve all the hate.

I don't see too much hate for these two - nor should there be! I would happily take either if I didn't already have a KIWId Jx-3p. Even then, I've seen some great deals I've been tempted with. Although sonically I still choose the 3P over its successors there's not that much in it.

[nathanscribe]

And I don't know of any [soft-synths] that offer multiple operator waveforms like the TX81Z does, which is key to its wide range of sound for a 4-op FM synth...

Just for interest: hardware-wise, 4-op FM with multiple waveforms are the TX81Z, DX11, V50 and TQ5.

I don't know of any of the 6-op hardware synths with anything more than sine waves, but you do get more algorithms to modulate the modulators...

The SY/TG FM units had way more than that, and at least the 77 can use its onboard samples as FM operators.

[Pro5]

well if you meant the SY77 also had more than sine waves to use with FM (like TX81z etc) then yes it does. The rom samples are of course a different thing but can also be used in interested ways in the 77/99 with that RCM thingy-mag-gig going on.

I don't know of any of the 6-op hardware synths with anything more than sine waves

SY77 is a 6op hardware synth and does, I'm a bit confused as you seem to be acknowledging that the '77 has more than just sine waves yet say no 6op hardware does? - not picking fault just trying to clarify for whoever's reading.

So - the 77/99 has more than sine waves for FM and that is NOT including any of it's PCM samples/wave rom stuff.

[nathanscribe]

well if you meant the SY77 also had more than sine waves to use with FM (like TX81z etc) then yes it does. The rom samples are of course a different thing but can also be used in interested ways in the 77/99 with that RCM thingy-mag-gig going on.

From what I understood from when I had one, the 77's AWM waves could be employed in the FM algorithms. Correct me if I'm wrong. I didn't get that deep into the programming.

I don't know of any of the 6-op hardware synths with anything more than sine waves

SY77 is a 6op hardware synth and does, I'm a bit confused as you seem to be acknowledging that the '77 has more than just sine waves yet say no 6op hardware does? - not picking fault just trying to clarify for whoever's reading.

Yep, I was referring (clumsily) to the DX-era FM synths

[Pro5]

well if you meant the SY77 also had more than sine waves to use with FM (like TX81z etc) then yes it does. The rom samples are of course a different thing but can also be used in interested ways in the 77/99 with that RCM thingy-mag-gig going on.

From what I understood from when I had one, the 77's AWM waves could be employed in the FM algorithms. Correct me if I'm wrong. I didn't get that deep into the programming.

I don't know of any of the 6-op hardware synths with anything more than sine waves

SY77 is a 6op hardware synth and does, I'm a bit confused as you seem to be acknowledging that the '77 has more than just sine waves yet say no 6op hardware does? - not picking fault just trying to clarify for whoever's reading.

Yep, I was referring (clumsily) to the DX-era FM synths

Yes the AWM waveforms certainly can be used with the FM, I was just clarifying that in addition the FM section alone has multiple (16 I think) waveforms to use not just the sine wave. So a bit of a beast really!

[nathanscribe]

Yep, 16 waves and more algorithms than the DX era stuff too. Two FM layers and two AWM layers per patch make it pretty epic...

More back on topic, I had an SY77 alongside a JX-10 (with PG-800) for a while. A great pair for epic soundtrack-style stuff. I've parted with both these synths now, but they are both bargains at current prices, especially if you don't mind tackling the depth of the SY, and can get a PG or similar device to work with the JX.

But yeah, they were too good for me, I like a bit of rough.

[vuuv]

welp i totally went and splurged and got a j3xp w/ the programmer and it's the best