Machinedrum vs. Xbase 888

[Polarelch]

Which has the better, more capable, flexible song editor?
Which is more fun / easy to use?
And which is better for sequencing other hardware?

[syntheticsolutions]

Which has the better, more capable, flexible song editor?
Which is more fun / easy to use?
And which is better for sequencing other hardware?

The machinedrum is much more capable with song editing, the parameter locks, combined with all the controls over the sound synthesis and routing and LFO's etc make this a limitless machine.

I find the machinedrum sequencer extremely fun to use, as far as live control goes, i would guess the Xbase is a bit more direct and hands on. you have full analog control over the sounds where as the machinedrum utilises different programming screens (flexible but not as direct as you may like in a live situation)

As far as sequencing external hardware goes, the machinedrum is fantastic. you simply place notes out on a midi track and use the parameter locks to change the note. i regularly use mine to sequence other gear (Great in a live situation)
Im not sure how the Xbase sequences external gear, it has midi so sequencing will be possible but maybe limited?

The main thing not mentioned is the sound, they couldn't be further apart in relation to tone.
The machinedrum is rather lo-fi and crisp. its very sharp and digital sounding. it has a metallic edge to it and can produce some very unique sounding rhythms.

The Xbase is analog and based on the 808 so will sound absolutely huge and ballsy. From what i have heard they sound incredible. if you want that vintage analogue beefy sound then the Xbase is probably the one for you, if you want a powerful groovebox/sequencer/sampler then maybe consider the machinedrum.